In this episode
- The conditions faced by migrants and asylum seekers at the U.S.-Mexico border
- U.S. policies including illegal waitlists, family separation, and the Migrant Protection Protocol
- How Al Otro Lado provides legal orientation, "Know Your Rights" sessions, and wraparound services in Tijuana
- The trauma-informed, supportive space the Border Rights Project creates for asylum seekers
- How Al Otro Lado reunited 29 families who had been separated
Meet the guest
Alejandra Martinez is the workshop coordinator of the Border Rights Project of Al Otro Lado, a binational social justice legal services organization. Al Otro Lado serves deportees, migrants and refugees in Tijuana, Mexico, and in San Diego and Los Angeles, California.
Links and resources
Key Takeaways
Seeking asylum is a legal right, and making people wait at the border for months puts those already at risk in more danger
Dignified treatment and a safe space come first, because asylum seekers arrive tired, desperate, and carrying trauma
Having a lawyer dramatically raises the odds of winning asylum, so access to legal help is an equity issue
Pro bono attorneys and volunteers make the work possible, and seeing it first-hand helps people bring the story home
Stay In The Know
Join our email list and you’ll get our newsletter (In The Know), new podcast episode announcements, course releases, and early access when new offerings drop. No noise. Just the work.
SUBSCRIBETranscript
Welcome to Doin’ The Work, Front Line Stories of Social Change where we bring you stories of real people working to address real issues. I am your host Shimon Cohen. Hey everyone, this is Shimon. Thanks so much for listening to Doin’ The Work. It's important to note that this episode was recorded before the Coronavirus pandemic. I hope everyone, your family, friends and communities are doing okay.
At the end of the interview, Alejandra talks about the need for people to go to Mexico to help Al Otro Lado with their work. Because of the Coronavirus pandemic Al Otro Lado is currently providing remote assistance. If you are interested in helping in the ways Alejandra mentions at the end of the episode, please get in touch with Al Otro Lado to see how you can help remotely during this critical time.

Free Anti-Oppressive Practice Reflection Tool
Understand how systems of power, privilege, and oppression shape our lives, our clients’ realities, and our professional decisions.
DOWNLOAD THE FREE TOOLCheck Out The Full Transcript
Shimon Cohen:
Welcome to Doin’ The Work, Front Line Stories of Social Change where we bring you stories of real people working to address real issues. I am your host Shimon Cohen. Hey everyone, this is Shimon. Thanks so much for listening to Doin’ The Work. It's important to note that this episode was recorded before the Coronavirus pandemic. I hope everyone, your family, friends and communities are doing okay.
At the end of the interview, Alejandra talks about the need for people to go to Mexico to help Al Otro Lado with their work. Because of the Coronavirus pandemic Al Otro Lado is currently providing remote assistance. If you are interested in helping in the ways Alejandra mentions at the end of the episode, please get in touch with Al Otro Lado to see how you can help remotely during this critical time.
In this episode I talk with Alejandra Martinez, who is the workshop coordinator of the Border Rights Project of Al Otro Lado, a binational social justice legal services organization serving deportees, migrants and refugees in Tijuana, Mexico and San Diego and Los Angeles, California. Alejandra talks about the incredibly challenging conditions faced by people who are migrating and seeking asylum and the inhumane U.S. policies such as an illegal waitlist, the highly controversial family separation, and the MPP Migrant Protection Protocol law, also known as the Remain in Mexican Policy, as well as how U.S. asylum procedures are constantly changing and unpredictable.
She explains that she and her team provide a safe, supportive space in Tijuana where they acknowledge the trauma and long journey any asylum seekers and migrants have experienced. Alejandra discusses how the Border Rights Project provides legal orientation and a know your rights session for asylum seekers as well as connects them to additional services such as shelters and medical care. She tells how Al Otro Lado recently reunited 29 families who had been separated and she shares how she got into this work. I hope this conversation inspires you to action. Hola, Alejandra.
Thank you so much for coming on the podcast. And to get things started, could you tell the listeners what you currently do?
Alejandra Martinez:
Of course. Thank you, Shimon. My name is Alejandra Martinez. I am the workshop coordinator for the Border Rights Project. It is a project that we have here down in Tijuana. So what we do here is we provide legal orientation for asylum seekers who are trying to apply for asylum in the U.S. We give them an orientation. We also give them a know your rights session. We explain to them their rights, the asylum process, and also we help them if they happen to be MPPs. This is a new, well, it started back in January, 2019.
It is a new policy where they send asylum seekers from Spanish speaking countries back to Mexico to wait for their hearings here. That means that their access, since they are in Mexico waiting for their hearings, their legal access or access to any type of advocacy is very limited. So we help them, if they happen to have their hearings closed, their cases terminated or any injustice happen during the process, we try to interfere there and do what we can.
Shimon Cohen:
It's really important work that you are doing. And, you know, a lot of the folks who listen to this podcast are social workers and social work students and social work educators, and so I was hoping that you could share some of what you think is the most important information about the issues that the people you are helping are facing, you know, on a daily basis that you think people who are listening to the podcast should know about.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yes, of course. So we work with vulnerable communities, with migrants who are fleeing persecution. So we always have to consider their emotional well being and all the trauma they have been through. So, and also to be aware of the different trauma responses that all human beings have and how to address that when, well, it comes in in the conversation, during an intake, et cetera. So most of the people we work with, they are living in shelters. Some people, they don't know where to live. They're living in the street.
They just arrived to Tijuana, there's care, et cetera. So we always need this like, humane treatment, this time to let them express themselves, make them feel comfortable, make them feel secure, make them feel that they do matter, because most of these people have been traveling for so long. Maybe not for so long, from very far away. Very long distances, so they have been extortion, cheated, abused, at other times during their travels. So once they get here to Tijuana finally to request asylum in the U.S. they are very tired and desperate.
So we always try to make them feel secure in their space. I think that is one of the most important things that we do here. We provide that safe space for the families. We provide un trato digno, that's how we say it in Spanish. It is dignified treatment, and we also try to help them with their basic needs. So here in our project we focus on legal orientation and legal-type of help, but we also work with other organizations that provide shelters, that provide food, that provide free medic services like medical clinics.
And we always try to furnish them with those services, because I believe that it's very important what we do here, but it's not the only thing that they need.
Shimon Cohen:
Right. They need a lot more than the legal support, even though that's critical. And so you're connecting them with other types of support and needs. Let's talk about the, let's talk about policy and the changing policy since the current, the Trump Administration. And you know, I know there was family separation under Obama. There was deportation. Not at the levels that it is at from what I understand now. So, could you, I think we have enough time to talk about a couple of these different ways, but I want to just start with, a lot of people I think don't understand that asylum seeking is legal. It is a legal right that people have. So could you talk about that a little bit?
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah, so asylum is a type of international protection that all human beings has the right to ask for. So when someone is no longer safe, I think people often don't realize or differentiate the difference between migration and being asylum seeker. I am a full supporter of both. But now that we are talking about the asylum seeker, when you are seeking asylum it's because you are fleeing persecution. That means that someone has done you like, very bad harm or someone is planning to do you very bad harm. So you have to flee.
Alone or with your family you have to flee, literally with the clothes you have on. Sometimes you have time to grab some documents, grab luggage or something like that, but most of the time you don't. You flee. And it's their right to go, right now we're talking about the United States, so it's their right to enter the United States and ask for asylum. It doesn't matter how they enter the United States through a port of entry or with an inspection. They have the right to request asylum.
And many times this right is being denied to them, and they have been returned back to Tijuana or to any like, border city between the states and Mexico, and they are forced to align up in, or to put their names in a wait list. This wait list is illegal. And though Mexican immigration officials are doing this in different ports of entry in different border cities with the states, they are making the asylum seekers to write their names in this wait list and wait a couple of months until their name, their turn comes so they can enter the United States to request asylum.
This is illegal. Supposedly no one should wait, not even one day to start the process to request asylum in the United States. In Mexico, especially Tijuana is not the safest city in the world. And making the people wait here, the people who are already at risk wait here in Tijuana. Tijuana is world-wide known for child trafficking, sex trafficking making people who are already vulnerable wait here for months to wait to ask for asylum in the U.S. is inhumane. It is very difficult to see that.
Shimon Cohen:
Right. So the U.S. government isn't following its own laws where people who are asylum seekers should be able to come in through a port of entry and start the process and remain in the U.S. while that's happening. They're getting rejected, and they're now in a situation where they've led their country because of violence, because of different issues that forced them to flee, and their risk has even increased, plus there's trauma as you talked about, so it creates a very unsafe situation.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah, that's true.
Shimon Cohen:
So with Al Otro Lado, you know, when you are working on the legal orientation for the asylum seekers, what kind of things do you go over with them?
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah. So we have two different type of intake forms. So we do one form, and we have one form for the people who are about to request asylum in the U.S. And most of them are Spanish speakers, but we have served people from over 50 different countries in a lot of different languages. So the orientation we give them for the people who are about to request asylum is if they qualify or if they potentially, because everything we advise here is potential. If they potentially qualify for the basis of asylum, for the protected grounds.
So in the United States in order to receive asylum, whatever happened to you, needs to be because of your nationality, your race, your religion, your political view or because you are from a specific social group. So we explore those parts of the claim and the lawyers that are the negotiation attorneys from the U.S. are the ones who review the intakes and give them the orientation.
We also have things about, we call it data about their journey, if something happened to them here in Mexico if they're not Mexicans, like during their travels here in the country, if they're traveling with family members, et cetera, and some other demographics. The second, the other intake form is the intake form for the MPPs. As I said before, the MPPs are the people who are already in proceedings to request asylum in the U.S. but the U.S. decide that it will be best for them to wait in Mexico.
So they should present themselves at the port of entry, they're given a date, and go to their hearings and then come back to Mexico. This is also problematic, but what we do here, the people under the MPP, we also give them a legal orientation about their claim in case that didn't came with us beforehand. And we also explore if they have had any type of problem during their hearings, or if anyone prevent them to enter through the port of entry.
So attend one of their hearings, and whenever the judge gave them the I-589, that's the asylum application, we help them pro bono to fill that out.
Shimon Cohen:
What does MPP stand for?
Alejandra Martinez:
Migrant Protection Protocol.
Shimon Cohen:
Okay. And those are the people who come over, but then get sent back while they're pending their case.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah.
Shimon Cohen:
You were talking about the different kind of like, ways that people qualify to be asylum seekers. And, you know, something that was talked about a lot a couple years ago was when the Attorney General Jeff Sessions, who isn't anymore, but when he was, he made a big statement about how domestic violence survivors were no longer, or were not going to be considered a protected group. So I'm assuming you see a lot of people, especially women who are fleeing domestic violence, their lives are at serious, serious risk. What happens there?
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah, we have seen a lot of cases of domestic violence, a lot of cases where women are treated as objects, and a lot of cases where the perpetrator of those domestic violence cases are following them, already found them in Mexican or here in Tijuana. So they're in that immediate risk of harm. So the Attorney General made a suggestion that the domestic violence along with family, those based claims, or, so it was a suggestion. So domestic violence claims, based claims along with family-based claims they're not as strong as they used to. But they still qualify as a base for asylum. So they are not strong. They are like more weak than they used to be, but they still qualify as a base for asylum.
Shimon Cohen:
That's really important information to have. Thank you for clarifying that.
Alejandra Martinez:
Also, like the basis for asylum, you can qualify for, you don't only have to qualify in one. You can qualify in multiple. Multiple. So your claim can be because of your race, domestic violence, and other things. It not have to be only one base. You can have multiple bases.
Shimon Cohen:
Does it make for a stronger case the more ways, the more kind of areas that someone has?
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah. Well, every case is different. But yeah, in the case where the basis is not very strong as we're talking about domestic violence or family, it's always good to look at other areas.
Shimon Cohen:
Does Al Otro Lado also work on, you know, policy change inside of the United States in terms of, you know, how people qualify, you know, this whole issue that's going on where the U.S. government's not following the law, is there pressure that's being done as well from, you know, legal advocates inside the United States?
Alejandra Martinez:
Yes. Actually, the most recent one that I have like on the tip of my head was that this new rule in the states about the third safe country, that means that people who entered the states after a certain date and they cross during their journey to any other country, like basically everyone who is requesting asylum in the U.S. after July 16, and they're Mexican or Canadian.
Like all the other countries that are not neighbors from the U.S. they are being obligated to request asylum in any other country that the United States qualifies as safe, before, as in before requesting asylum in the U.S. So for example if you are someone from Honduras that is not very safe, the country. And you request, you go, went through Guatemala and Mexico, before you go to request asylum to the U.S. United States will ask you to ask for asylum in one of those countries because for the United States Mexico and Honduras are safe countries.
So if you cross one of those countries, you should have been like, requesting asylum there. And if your asylum is denied, now you can ask asylum for the U.S. We are against that, because clearly these countries, because I am in Mexico right now, are not safe. But so, what we did here is that as I mentioned previously the system of the wait list prevent a lot of people to request asylum in the U.S. So this new rule is from July 16 on.
But what's happened with all the people that got to a border city, in this case to Tijuana, before July 16 but because this illegal list, they were forced to wait several months here and they entered the U.S. to request asylum afterwards. But not because they got here after July 16, because they got here previously but they were forced to wait in the waiting list. So what we were able to do is that to make for the people who signed up in the illegal wait list before July 16, to not be affected in this new policy.
Shimon Cohen:
Right. The wait list was going to push them past the cutoff date, but you were able to get them included before that change so they could apply directly for asylum in the U.S. rather than going through another one of the other countries.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah.
Shimon Cohen:
You know, another policy I really wanted to get your thoughts on is the family separation, because it has been devastating. And I wanted to just, I mean, you see this every day with, right, with what's happening with families, parents who are being deported, their kids are remaining in the U.S. There's been reports that these children are getting forced into adoption without their parents' consent. So I just wanted to get your thoughts on all of that.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah. So, this is an issue that we deal with this every day in different areas. So we have an obligation to inform everyone who comes into our clinic about the family separation issues and risks. So it's sometimes it's during the know your rights session. Sometimes another colleague does it. But when they do during the know your rights session, this part is especially difficult for me, because you're in front of the clients. We call them clients, because we couldn't figure out a better word. But you're in front of the individuals who are seeking asylum.
And when you talk about the possibilities of being separated in the “icebox,” because this is where everything happens, at the beginning of the process, so they are being held in the facilities called the “icebox” - the hielera - and there is where parents that are traveling with their biological or legally adopted children, they have documentation about the relationship, and they don't represent any harm to the minor, they still get separated, even if they have documentation. And to have to tell that to the individuals, the asylum seekers who are in the clinics, it's very hard.
Sometimes mothers and parents in general, they start, they seem very much emotionally distressed with this information. This is a reality. We have to interfere to reunite 29 families a couple of months ago back in 2019 because they cross, they entered the hielera - the “icebox,” they were separated from their children, they start their asylum process, because supposedly when you get separated you get reunited when your asylum process end. Either if you won asylum or you lose and you get deported. That is supposedly.
Because in this case all these families have, as you were saying, got deported to their home countries and the kids stay in the U.S. They didn't try to reunificate them or anything. It's like the United States kidnap the kids.
Shimon Cohen:
Yeah. Absolutely.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah. So we had to intervene there and litigate so we can reunificate those families. We did it, we reunificate those 29 families. That's something that is happening nowadays. And we hear different type of family separation, separation where they're only apart while they're in the icebox for a couple of days, separations where they are apart for months. Separations where they are apart even when the parents are being deported. So it's changing and it's unpredictable. And that is one of the worst things that when people is asking you, are asking you like, so what will happen?
They want a more clear path to know what to expect. We give to them all the possible potential scenarios, but there's no one, like one clear path, because there's so many things that can happen and so unpredictable. There are some people for example that stays in the icebox - in the hielera - for three days. There are people that stays there 19 or 20 days. So everything is so unpredictable in the asylum process in the U.S.
Shimon Cohen:
Yeah. And it's constantly changing, and the information, you know, I understand what you are saying like, you can't, people can't depend on this is the process, because that's just not the way it works. And when they instituted this policy, they never planned, my, I mean, from what I understand is that they never planned, the government never planned to reunite the families. They didn't develop a way to track them, they you know, deport the parents, they say they don't know where the kids are. And you know, just to share my opinion, I think it's absolutely unacceptable, I think it's a human rights violation, it is state sanctioned kidnapping, and you know, there needs to be legislation or something passed that forces the government to reunite these families.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah, we even tell the people who we serve here that when they're crossing to write in their children's arms with permanent marker their information not the children's information but the information about the parent so if ICE lose them they can see on their arm who are the parents, so they can put them back together.
Shimon Cohen:
Wow. Wow.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah, it's very hard to see, especially very hard to see the clients receiving this information. I think that's one of the most difficult parts of this job.
Shimon Cohen:
You know, one of the things I was going to ask you is what are some of the biggest challenges of what you do. So you know, that's one of them. What do you think is another challenge in terms of you know, social change, social justice, really getting like, these bigger changes to happen?
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah. Well, I think one of the most like, the biggest thing in social, like imparity - that is a word in English?
Shimon Cohen:
Inequality or inequity.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yes, the access to legal services. So, the percentage of asylum seekers that get legal representation, because we don't, here in the clinic in the Border Rights Project, we don't represent individuals. We only give orientation. But the percentage of asylum seekers that get legal representation is very low. And having a lawyer, like to legally represent you, it increase your chances to win asylum like, dramatically. So I think also this is like related to like, economic inequity, income inequity, because not all people has the ability to hire a lawyer.
But this is, I think this is one of the things that impact more asylum seekers that not all have the chance or the means to hire a lawyer. And I think this should change. We do work pro bono, and we work with other organizations that do pro bono work, but we're in a crisis here at the border. We need more attorneys who can do pro bono work, because the clients really need it.
Shimon Cohen:
Yeah, I'm going to provide some information in the show notes of the podcast so that people can, listeners can get in touch with your organization hopefully to support the important work that you are doing, because every little bit of help I'm sure is beneficial. You know, I wanted to ask you before we finish, how did you get into doing this work?
Alejandra Martinez:
So I was born and raised in Tijuana, so I got to see like, migration first hand. Tijuana is a very young city, like around 150 years. And everyone that is living here is, well, not everyone right, but most of the people who's living here are migrants. Like my mom is from Mexico City, my grandma is from another part of Mexico, et cetera. And we were always also like, we see first hand the reality of the parties, because they are sent here to the border.
So we see directly when the parties arrive and the situation, the vulnerabilities of those situations. So I was always very aware of the migration issues or situation, to say it like that. And I got, when I was like, in high school and university I started getting involved in social projects with vulnerable communities, but I was working mostly with kids. Then I got to, I went to another non-profit in Nicaragua for one year and a half. I was a volunteer coordinator. And I had to leave Nicaragua because of the political problem that happened.
And even though I was working a non-profit for kids, because it was what I just do, I got very touched about how someone, and I'm from Mexico, that our political situation is not very well. But to see that the Nicaragua people were directly affected with everything about, with everything that was happening in 2018, that really touched me. Then a couple of months later, one of the first caravan, the biggest caravan from Honduras arrived here in Mexico and people from Central America joined the caravan so I wanted to get involved there. And I get involved.
I start going to the shelters to provide food and help in the donation centers to organize the donations, cooking for the shelters, for the community, and then I found Al Otro Lado and I started volunteering there and then they hired me, and I'm still here. It has been like, a creative path.
Shimon Cohen:
Yeah. It's quite a journey. I'm sure you've seen a lot along this path you've taken.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yeah.
Shimon Cohen:
So I want to, you know, before we finish I also just want to give you the opportunity if you have anything else you want to share before we finish the interview, you know, now is your chance to use this podcast as a way to get out any message you want to.
Alejandra Martinez:
Yes, of course. So here in the Border Rights Project we have very small staffing. We are about like, seven staff members. But we make all this possible thanks to the interns, long-term volunteers and short-term volunteers. We have served I think like 6,000 asylum seekers here in this project. And nothing of this is possible, we run like with very little resources. If you get to come here, you will see. But nothing of this will be possible if we wouldn't have the support of the volunteers.
So if you have one week of your time, one week off that you can take a vacation or if you are in school, if you are studying and you can take, and you would like to do an internship or something like that, come visit us. The Border Rights Project is always in need of volunteers, pro bono immigration attorneys, interns, long term, and it's a very impactful experience. And be able to see this first-hand and go back to your hometown and tell everyone, your friends, your family what you saw is very powerful.
Because one thing to see it on the news or read about it. Another thing to see it first hand. So if you have the opportunity to come here, I think one of the most effective ways to bring awareness to your community is to share experiences mouth to mouth and live in it. So if you want to come, just go to our website alotrolado.org and register yourself to volunteer in the Border Rights Project, and we will see each other here.
Shimon Cohen:
Thank you so much for sharing that, and I hope that people listening are able to go. And you know, I just want to thank you again for coming on the podcast and also I want to say gracias por hacer el trabajo en la comunidad. Muchas gracias por todo que tú hace.
Alejandra Martinez:
Gracias Shimon. Thank you so much.
Shimon Cohen:
Thank you for listening to Doin’ The Work, Frontline Stories of Social Change. I hope you enjoyed the podcast. Please follow on Twitter and leave positive reviews on iTunes. If you are interested in being a guest or know someone who is doing great work, please get in touch. And thank you for doing real work to make this world a better place.
Music credit:
“District Four” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

