In this episode
- Dementia research and how it led to community-based work in Tuskegee
- The history of unethical and racist research practices and their lasting impact on community trust
- The unique challenges facing rural communities and the role of researchers and practitioners
- Supporting self-determination among individuals, families, and communities
- How to get involved in policy advocacy—with concrete examples
Meet the guest
Dr. Nicole Ruggiano is an associate professor in the School of Social Work at the University of Alabama. She is a John A. Hartford Geriatric Social Work Scholar.
Links and resources
Key Takeaways
Rural dementia caregivers may want support groups but cannot leave the person they care for to drive an hour or more
Researchers should be flexible to adjust to what community members say they really need
Returning again and again, and teaching the topics the community asked for, builds trust in a place that has been harmed by researchers
Watered down self-determination offers choices A, B, or C that the social worker already approved
Stay In The Know
Join our email list and you’ll get our newsletter (In The Know), new podcast episode announcements, course releases, and early access when new offerings drop. No noise. Just the work.
SUBSCRIBETranscript
Welcome to Doin’ The Work, frontline stories of social change, where we bring these stories of real people working to address real issues. I am your host, Shimon Cohen. In this episode I talk with Nicole Ruggiano who is an associate professor in the School of Social Work at the University of Alabama. We talk about Nicola's research on dementia, and how it led to working with the community of Tuskegee, where there is a history of unethical and racist practices by researchers. Nicole shares about the challenges facing rural communities and the importance of researchers, academics and practitioners in supporting self-determination among individuals, families and communities. Nicole urges listeners to get involved with policy advocacy and provides examples of how to do so. I hope you enjoy the conversation. For this episode of Doin’ The Work, frontline stories of social change. I am here with Dr. Nicole Ruggiano, associate professor in the School of Social Work at the University, Alabama. Nicole is a John A Hartford Geriatric Social Work Scholar. Hey Nicole. Thanks for joining me on the podcast.
Thanks for inviting me Shimon.

Free Anti-Oppressive Practice Reflection Tool
Understand how systems of power, privilege, and oppression shape our lives, our clients’ realities, and our professional decisions.
DOWNLOAD THE FREE TOOLCheck Out The Full Transcript
Shimon Cohen:
Welcome to Doin’ The Work, frontline stories of social change, where we bring these stories of real people working to address real issues. I am your host, Shimon Cohen. In this episode I talk with Nicole Ruggiano who is an associate professor in the School of Social Work at the University of Alabama. We talk about Nicola's research on dementia, and how it led to working with the community of Tuskegee, where there is a history of unethical and racist practices by researchers. Nicole shares about the challenges facing rural communities and the importance of researchers, academics and practitioners in supporting self-determination among individuals, families and communities. Nicole urges listeners to get involved with policy advocacy and provides examples of how to do so. I hope you enjoy the conversation. For this episode of Doin’ The Work, frontline stories of social change. I am here with Dr. Nicole Ruggiano, associate professor in the School of Social Work at the University, Alabama. Nicole is a John A Hartford Geriatric Social Work Scholar. Hey Nicole. Thanks for joining me on the podcast.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Thanks for inviting me Shimon.
Shimon Cohen:
I'm really excited to talk with you about what you're currently up to, so maybe you could just start with that.
Nicole Ruggiano:
As you mentioned, I'm a John A Hartford Geriatric Social Work scholar, and what that means is that as a researcher and a social worker, I focused a lot of my career on aging and issues of aging. Part of that has been in dementia care, dementia caregiving, which has led me to a lot of the work that I'm currently doing in Alabama. First of all, I started my career in Miami, Florida, which has no shortage of older people. So, a lot of the work that we've done there has been developing interventions for caregivers of people with dementia. To help them navigate the health and social service arenas. But, now I'm in Alabama and dealing with a lot of rural issues and dementia and that's been a lot different than what I've seen in more urban areas.
Shimon Cohen:
That goes right into the next question I was going to ask you, which is what are the unique challenges facing the population that you're working with?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, in rural Alabama, and this is the first time I've lived in a rural area. I grew up in Philadelphia. I moved to Miami as an adult and now I live in Birmingham. But, really my work takes place across the whole entire state of Alabama because the rural communities are very much spread out and they're very much in need of services. Here we have individuals who, they are living far apart from services or maybe if they need multiple services, those are far away from one another. They have to rely very heavily on a car, internet service. High-speed internet might not be available. So, the issue of access is significant. I've been all over in Northern Alabama, Western, Southern Alabama. In fact, one day I was on the way to working in a rural community and I made a wrong turn and I ended up in Mississippi. So, I've learned a lot about doing work in rural areas.
Shimon Cohen:
What kind of work are you doing? You mentioned access being a major issue and people needing services. Are those the kind of interventions that you're doing?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Yes, definitely. How this started was, my group has been developing a caregiving app for dementia caregivers to use in partnership with the people with dementia, their providers. What my current study is doing, is going across the state and showing the app to caregivers. It's not available for download or purchase yet, but showing them a prototype of it. And getting their opinions. Within these interviews ,I have found so many things that have been problematic for these caregivers that for instance, many caregivers said that they would like to participate in caregiver support groups, but they can't leave the person that they're caring for alone for up to an hour so they can drive 30, 45 minutes each way or more to get to a caregiver support group. There's another problem that much of the dementia care in these areas are dealt with by primary care physicians and not specialists.
So, they might not have the extensive training that's needed to deal with a complex condition like dementia. One woman who was in a focus group mentioned her father was diagnosed with a term that I later found out has not been used in neurology for over 30 years. So, in addition to pursuing big research projects, I've also been applying for smaller blocks of money, 10,000, 20,000. it doesn't sound big, but it's ... It sounds like a good amount of money, but in terms of developing a new program, that gets used up very quickly.
Shimon Cohen:
Right, right. That's going to go very quickly. What kind of programs are these that you're developing?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Right now I have two grants pending for two different programs, related to the work that I've learned through my research. One is to develop private Facebook groups, to use them as a platform for developing dementia caregiving support groups. People who are in rural areas but have access to Facebook, which is a very familiar for many people, electronic platform. It's also free, so we don't have to pay for licensing or the development of the software. You can develop private groups, where we only invite people who are part of the program in, and they can participate in a support group with people from all other places in Alabama. This is beneficial for a number of reasons that people have, others who are experiencing the same thing, to talk to about their feelings and the stress and burden that they're experiencing. But, also to learn from one another and learn strategies on how to deal with difficult behaviors of the person they're caring for.
Shimon Cohen:
What timeline are you looking at with these projects?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, that project we're looking at a year-long project, and basically trying to see the feasibility of having two or three groups. Now, I am not the first person to invent this concept. I have colleagues in Missouri who are actually doing this with hospice caregivers, and they have a large research grant to do this with hospice caregivers, that they draw from the same hospice center. They pick some hospice centers and talk to the people there if they want to participate. The difference with my project is, I want to reach out to people who aren't really getting a lot of services and that they can get more connected. So, if we can demonstrate, that grant is a $6,000 grant, and so it's very small and the plan is to have social work students run the support groups.
But if we can demonstrate that it's feasible, then that would give us the information we need to ask the federal government for some more money, maybe $100,000 or $275,000. Those are the sizes of different grants to do a larger project. Technically, it's still considered research, but it's also putting services and resources in the hands that people need them.
Shimon Cohen:
Absolutely. The second project you're working on?
Nicole Ruggiano:
The other project I'm working on, and this is, in Tuskegee, Alabama, which has a terrible history of healthcare practices and research practices. So, it's not necessarily an easy community to do health research in. So, as a health researcher, I've been doing these interviews, as I mentioned. I had somebody from Tuskegee call me and say, "We have a caregiver support group. Would you be able to interview the support group in a single interview?"
I said, "Okay." I planned to do a focus group in the community and I said, "How many people will probably be there?" She said. "Maybe five, six, seven." When I showed up there, about 20 people had been there and what I found is that, we even had to abandon the focus group questions that I prepared because they wanted to talk about how there's nothing there for them. They don't have enough information about dementia. They can't talk to the providers there and they don't think that the providers are prepared. Using that information, there is a community foundation of Central Alabama, and they provide grants for health and wellbeing for families, projects that target that. So, for a $25,000 grant, I proposed a full-day conference that would be for caregivers, but also for physicians, nurses and social workers.
Part of the money would actually go to purchase and process their CEUs to get them to come out and do it, so caregivers and providers in Tuskegee can learn about dementia from experts across the country that we bring in as part of the project. This is information that none of these people would necessarily have access to. So, for a full day they can receive education and training, but also because the caregivers report that they don't think that the providers understand what they're going through. This way they can learn side-by-side and also develop a mutual understanding about what's going on with dementia care in the community.
Shimon Cohen:
I think that's so amazing for a number of reasons. One that, you went out there and you had a certain plan, but then you were responsive to the needs of the community. Could you speak to that a little bit?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, it's interesting. When I first went to Tuskegee for that first focus group. And when I learned how little there was in the community, and how much pain that these individuals are experiencing because they don't feel like they have, they're provided all the tools that they need in order to provide good care and to make good healthcare decisions about the people they're taking care of. I mean, I left there in tears, after I left, just seeing how stressful it was for them. What I recognize is that some of these communities that we work in, and including Tuskegee has had so many people beforehand turn their backs on them. I decided that's not what I wanted to do. It's not an easy community for me to access. It's a two- hour drive each way.
But, since that first focus group, I've gone back and have done educational sessions with caregivers. I'm doing another one next month. This is anything that I get paid in addition for or as part of my job duties, but making sure that they get the information that they need. It also is helpful because the more I can get individuals to come out, and more people come out every time I come back. The more I can get them engaged, the easier it is for support. For example, the University of Alabama at Birmingham, which is different than the University of Alabama in Tuscaloosa where I am, they have a large medical school with a neurology department and I work with the neurologist on some of my research. When I told them about going to Tuskegee, and how many people are coming out, they started asking if they can come with me in future trips and do talks because they actually would like to connect with the caregivers and people with dementia in the community for some of their projects and some of the services they offer.
We even started talking about the potential of having a free telemedicine sessions, where they can get evaluations and assessments that UAB will use as they try to learn more about dementia, but also would be a free resource and something that's educational for the people living in Tuskegee. Making those connections are very important because the neurologists don't think from their perspective, "Oh, I need to go to the community centers and do talks once a month."
Shimon Cohen:
Right.
Nicole Ruggiano:
But, that's what a social worker would think.
Shimon Cohen:
Right. That's a great partnership to have and provide that education to them. Then, they know this community is going to be responsive.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Yes. I mean they, it's about trust in these communities.
Shimon Cohen:
Absolutely.
Nicole Ruggiano:
They trust me, and so if I can bring people who, not only do I trust, but I trust would not take advantage of these opportunities in a wrong way. That's what's very important to me.
Shimon Cohen:
What's the biggest challenge of this work for you?
Nicole Ruggiano:
I actually think for rural social work it is the distance, because you're spending a lot of time just getting to where you need to be. If I'm trying to have meetings and they're five hours away each way, it takes up a lot of time. Whereas, if you're in more of an urban area, it's very easy to get to meetings and to meet with people in the community. I would actually say the distance is probably one of the biggest hurdles.
Shimon Cohen:
And there's really no way around that at this point. I mean, there's no fix for that.
Nicole Ruggiano:
No, there isn't. Especially when you're dealing with older people. The older people are using technology now more today than they were before. But for the purpose of things like teleconferencing and things that are a little more sophisticated, that can't be expected in these communities. To think that we could tell a conference via Skype, that might not be feasible.
Shimon Cohen:
Right. Right. Then also the trust factor. I mean, it's very hard to build trust that way.
Nicole Ruggiano:
I mean, I will say, as a white woman doing research in Tuskegee, I'm very surprised about the response that I've had. I think a lot of it is that they saw me come back. They see me coming back, and I'm responding to what they want. So, the talks that I give to them, are the topics that they tell me they know nothing about and they want to learn more.
Shimon Cohen:
That's great. Yeah, that's what I was saying before, that I think is just so important, is that you basically ditched your questions that you had planned and you were like, "I'm going to go with what they need." Not all researchers do that.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, not researchers, and honestly not all social workers.
Shimon Cohen:
True.
Nicole Ruggiano:
I think from a provider's standpoint, we tend to look at things like self- determination and what's best for the client, is what we think is best for the client. So I read so much about what is called, watered down self- determination, where a social worker might say, "I'm going to let you decide on what you want to do, but it's going to be either choices A, B, or C. because I think those are the best choices." That's not necessarily self- determination. It's basically saying ,you can pick from whatever I feel is acceptable.
Shimon Cohen:
Absolutely. Watered down, self-determination.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Yeah. Well, and especially when we're dealing with older people, research shows that social workers tend to have a more difficult time promoting self- determination, because they view the population as vulnerable. So, sometimes we really have to think about whether the decision somebody's making, to what extent are they able to make that decision, and if they're making a risky decision, is it something that they still have the right to make?
Shimon Cohen:
Absolutely. One of the aspects of this podcast that I wanted to do, that's a little different than some other ones, is just to ask on a more personal level, how did you get into this work, this area, you this field, however you want to answer that question?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, I think my first times thinking about aging and health were actually after my grandfather ... I think as social workers we all have some personal story, but when my grandfather had a stroke, this was the first time I had to start taking him and my grandmother to their doctor's visit. I realized that they asked no questions. The doctor would just give them a prescription. They didn't ask anything about it or advocate for themselves. I realized that we have a health and social service system that really treats older people like they're passive service users. So, I wanted to do a lot more to promote self-advocacy, health literacy and self-determination and autonomy of older people. So, when I was a Hartford scholar, part of that was $100,000 grant to conduct a research project. I focused on how older adults with chronic conditions, not dementia or cognitive decline, but how do those with conditions like cancer and heart disease and other conditions, how did they make decisions about their care and how did they interact with the professionals that they receive care from?
I learned a lot about how little control they felt, not that they had, but what people allowed them to have, that they felt like it was very constrained. That people hide information from them, that they don't give them the entire information. But, at the same time I started to do some work with dementia care, and I learned that caregivers were going through some of the similar things. I looked at both groups, older adults with chronic conditions and caregivers, as being these individuals in the health and social service systems that really needed a lot of support, so that they can make decisions that best help reach their quality of life, that they would like to achieve.
Shimon Cohen:
It's fascinating. How long ago was this, when you started down down this path?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Oh my goodness. Well, let's see. It was while I was a graduate student, so maybe like the mid-2000s, so it was some time ago. But, it takes a lot when you're an academic to build a career. So, here we are in 2018. And I got my PhD about 10 years ago. I'm just now at the point where I can go for larger grants and have more autonomy in my work. Not having to worry about tenure anymore, allows me do write papers, to go for research grants, but also to promote these projects as well. I'm also very active in public policy and connecting with legislators and other public policy figures. In letting them know what is going on in the front lines.
Shimon Cohen:
That's awesome. That's one of the things that I'm hoping to really get talking about with people too, is that link between practice, research and policy advocacy. What's the biggest challenge of this work, in terms of real social change? What are the barriers there?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, Oh goodness, that could be a whole podcast.
Shimon Cohen:
Yeah, we could do a whole another episode about that.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, in terms of the work that I'm doing, I think that there are a lot of stereotypes about aging and older people that prevent us to look at them as just adults. That we separate them from all the rest of the adults, and there's something very specific about older people. There are people with cognitive decline. There are people with advanced dementia and they might not have the capacity to make everyday decisions about themselves. But, when we have a entire policies and program systems that treat all older people as if they're extremely vulnerable and not able to make decisions on their own, that's a big challenge. So, getting past the larger system barriers that are based on our stereotypes, that is very problematic. I think that, just needing more advocacy for older people is important as well.
Shimon Cohen:
What kind of policy change in Alabama are you currently working on?
Nicole Ruggiano:
In Alabama right now I'm actually, because I'm new to Alabama, I'm fairly new. I've only lived here a year and a half. Right now my main work is to try to connect with legislators. I think one of the first things that you need to do is to develop a relationship with legislators so that they're more open to what you have to say. Also that when they have questions about what's going on in the community, they come to you. At the university, I actually started an initiative that's been in full support of our Dean and faculty, and it's going to be hot off the press very soon. We came up with a 12-page booklet and it's called the School Social Work Faculty Expert Guide. It actually highlights, what our faculty can do with their expertise and knowledge, not just in their research, but in the communities that they work in.
What can they do for legislators? The fact that we have information about communities and how these larger issues we hear on CNN and Fox news and the national networks, how those are being played out in our local communities. We can answer those questions and that we know enough about policy and research on policy that we can tell them what policies have worked and not have worked in other areas. So, once that is in print, I'm actually going to start meeting with legislators next month in Washington,, and then in Montgomery and just do a lot of handshaking and say "Hi, this is who I am. This is what their school social work can do for you. Here's this booklet. It has a picture of all the faculty who wanted to be listed as a faculty expert and their contact information."
Shimon Cohen:
Did you do anything like that in Florida? Did you have relationships with legislators?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, Florida is a lot bigger in size then Alabama. I would say on the state level, no. But I will say in the local level, yes. I actually gave talks for the mayor's Initiative on Aging about transportation and health for older adults. I worked with a lot of advocacy organizations like the United Way of Florida, where I gave talks about policy advocacy among health and human service providers, and also worked with the United Way of Miami Dade County to give them information about how to best invest money for older people. I also worked with the Alliance for Aging in Miami, which is the area agency on aging. I will say, I did more on the local level in Miami, whereas Alabama, I feel like I need to do more on the state level.
Shimon Cohen:
Right. Part of that is probably because of the rural areas and how spread out everything is, right? That if you're local, you're not going to get to what's going on in all of those areas.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Correct. So, going to the state legislators and finding out who's best to talk to. For instance, two of our state legislators worked on a state task force for Alzheimer's, and they actually concluded that we need more technology-based solutions in order to reach vulnerable populations. Well I need to be in the offices of those legislators because that's exactly what I'm doing is trying to get more technology in the hands of caregivers of people with Alzheimer's.
Shimon Cohen:
How did you make that connection that they, how did you do the research onto these people, and know that they were on this committee, and that they had been part of this finding?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well in doing my research just on Alabama, because if we want to do intervention work locally, we need to know what's there, what's needed. So, I came across the task force report and their names are right on it. So those would be two people that I would take this expert guide, call up their office, say to their legislative aides, "Who should I talk to in your offensive about this?" Then make an appointment and introduce myself.
Shimon Cohen:
That's great. I think that's great for people, for the listeners to hear that, and follow similar models in their areas. Of course, it'll be different based on the area.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, what was really funny, we had a faculty meeting where I presented the expert guide and there were some field staff, so these are people who are MSW-level social workers, who are working more with students and with individuals who are working in the field with our students. When I started talking about the expert guide, one of the people from the field raised their hand, and they said, "You know, I'm doing a lot of work in child welfare. Do you think it would be appropriate if I was listed as an expert?" I said, "Yes, you do not need to have a PhD or be at a university even to be an expert in an area. If you're in the trenches every single day, you have knowledge to take to those legislators and let them know what's going on in the communities that they represent."
Shimon Cohen:
That's so absolutely true and refreshing to hear that coming from someone who does have a PhD.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Yeah. I said, I think what my comment was, "Being a PhD doesn't really make you an expert, but maybe I shouldn't say that in a room full of PhDs."
Shimon Cohen:
Yeah, I'm sure that would over well.
Nicole Ruggiano:
I mean, our practice experience is really what makes us special as social workers and makes us a unique perspective to give to legislators.
Shimon Cohen:
Nicole, how can folks listening to the podcast support the work you're doing?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, I take donations for all of these projects mentioning, but I think that the support needed is for everybody to find ways of working together, in order to develop evidence-based practice and evidence-based policy. So, it's not necessarily that your listeners need to support me, but I think that they need to find out who are the major stakeholders in the areas that they are working in, whether it's at the policy level or a state level executive branch, whether it's university faculty. Who is it that has the same mission and goals that they have that, they can work together in new ways to really promote social justice and and access to services in the areas that they're working.
Shimon Cohen:
Is there anything else you'd like to say or mention while you're on here?
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, I think that we shouldn't be scared of policy advocacy. That's something that is well-known that social workers do not typically feel prepared. I've talked a lot about that, but also remembering that we are experts. I think when social workers are in multidisciplinary settings, other disciplines don't necessarily understand what we do, and sometimes we end up being undervalued for our skills. I feel like in social workers, we need to stand up and say, "We are experts. We have all of this knowledge and these skills and that we bring a very important component to to the client population, to what they need." So, not feeling that, I guess feeling empowered as a social worker, as opposed to just somebody who's always in toe with other professionals, that we're there because we're important. We have something to contribute.
Shimon Cohen:
Absolutely. I think that's so critical. Nicole, thank you so much for coming on here and thank you for doing the work in your community, and all the work you do to improve things for other people. I look forward to hearing more about how these projects are going over time.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, maybe we can do followup episode.
Shimon Cohen:
Absolutely.
Nicole Ruggiano:
Well, I've enjoyed it. Thank you very much.
Shimon Cohen:
Thank you for listening to Doin’ The Work, frontline stories of social change. I hope you enjoyed the podcast. Please follow on Twitter and leave positive reviews on iTunes. If you're interested in being a guest or know someone who's doing great work, please get in touch and thank you for doing real work, to make this world a better place.
Music credit:
“District Four” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

